Premium Ingredients

Open daily 12-9pm

Ice Cream Cakes

At Bentley's, we can create just about anything with ice cream! All of our products are prepared on-site at our Nokomis store.

Novelties

Made to order treats with your favorite flavor of Bentley's Homemade Premium Ice Cream or Gelato like Sundaes, Shakes, Malts, Wizards, Pies and more.

Bentley's Homemade

At Bentley's, we use only fresh, quality ingredients to blend our Premium Hard-Packed and Soft-Serve Ice Cream, Gelato and Sorbet.

Main Menu:

Birthday Club

Bentley's wants to celebrate with you! Sign-up to get a free small sundae when you stop by our store in Nokomis during your birthday week . Sign up now.

Special Orders

Surprise that special someone with the gift of a delicious ice cream cake and pie. The Crew at Bentley's Homemade Ice Cream Store will create your cake or pie for any occasion. We do just about any design imaginable! CALL US at 941-375-8046 to order your cake, pie or other novelty, or, send us a description of what you need using our online Order Form.